Latest News

25th October 2007

Agencies criticise film exposé of Muslim missions

by Jenny Taylor

 

Steve Bell
Steve Bell

British mission agencies who were involved in the Dispatches film “Unholy War”, broadcast on Channel 4 on Monday, fear negative repercussions, after the film bracketed them with what they describe as “unaccountable” American evangelists.

The film investigated the plight of former Muslims in Britain who convert to Christianity, and reported the intimidation that many of them face from Muslims. While they are pleased that Islamic apostasy laws have been exposed, the agencies are dismayed at the tactics and tone that the film took regarding long-standing Christian work in inner cities.

Steve Bell, a team leader from Urban Vision, who was interviewed for more than two hours for the film, said this week: “They have pulled us into the same category as that insensitive, brash form of evangelism, when we have a different story to tell.”

Urban Vision is the UK wing of Interserve, a charity founded in 1852 by Lady Kinnaird. As the Bible and Medical Missionary Fellowship, it built hospitals and schools in India. Yet it was portrayed, to sinister background music, as a “covert group” that “targets” vulnerable Muslims.

Mr Bell said on Tuesday: “The film could potentially cause people in government to push for restrictions on interfaith mission because what they saw last night suggested that this is fomenting social unrest, and, as the reporter put it, ‘creating a time-bomb’.” The report suggested that “an explosion” was waiting to happen, caused by Christian proselytism.

The programme filmed the Revd Jay Smith, a Brethren in Christ evangelist who leads a Muslim outreach at Speakers’ Corner. He has no formal church links in the UK, but runs evangelism training courses at All Souls’, Langham Place, and elsewhere. The film also accused another US mission group, the Caleb Project, of “targeting” vulnerable women and children in Bradford.

Mr Smith said this week that his work was generously financed by British as well as American Christians. “The Establishment missiologists don’t like us because they always use the eirenic method. They’re afraid of directly confronting these aggressive Muslims. Why? We challenge the radicals using their own methodology. Someone has to do it.”

Mr Bell said: “The problem is a lack of sensitivity to the way British Christians do things. In an overseas situation, we would serve the work of local Christians, and respect their decision about an approach. They [the US evangelists] tend to ignore the British Church.”

Other church leaders were critical of the moral equivalence that the programme seemed to imply between Christian evangelism and Muslim religious intimidation, which its perpetrators see as sanctioned by Islam.

The Revd Chris Sugden, the Executive Secretary of Anglican Mainstream, said: “The notion that Christians might bring the love and comfort of God to people who have been bruised and battered by life is being attacked [by some in the media], who clearly believe that we should all be autonomous self-sufficient achievers.”

The Dispatches reporter, Antony Barnett, who is from a Jewish background, denied that there had been any pressure put on him to balance Christian and Muslim sides. He said, however, that “there was pressure to make the Caleb Project much more significant — which we decided against. It was put in out of journalistic curiosity.” He said that he had no idea what practical caring work missionaries did.

 

This story appeared in the Church Times on 21 September 2007.

Lapido Blog

Lapido Blog

Fitna: not for mice
08 Apr 2008

The Archbishop’s bomb
08 Feb 2008

Where was the Government?
01 Feb 2008

Who are we now?
08 Jan 2008

Read more »

 

 

Downloadable Publications

Christianity or Occult?Ethics in Brief

‘Women have borne the brunt of our failed multi-culturalism’, argues Jenny Taylor in Ethics in Brief Spring 2008 issue

More information »

 

Christianity or Occult?Christianity or Occult?

As cases of kindoki or ‘child witch’ abuse re-surface in Britain, a new downloadable report brings together material by leading African and English scholars from a recent symposium that throws light on some of the allegations.

More information »

 

Featured Publications

Crimes of the CommunityCrimes of the Community

A devastating report on the rise of "honour-based" violence against women from immigrant communities in the UK. It is devastating not just because it reveals the complicity of some "community leaders" in killings, attempted murder and beatings, but also because its sources are so authoritative...

More information »

 

Young, British and MuslimYoung, British and Muslim

'A most important book on British Muslims. It explodes many contemporary stereotypes to reveal a picture which is far more complex than is often supposed. It shines a light onto both new areas of menace and new avenues of hope. Every politician and policy-maker should read it.'
Paul Vallely, The Independent

More information »

 

Conviction and ConflictConviction and Conflict

Bishop Michael Nazir-Ali sets out fundamental guidelines on the role of religion in society and its relationship to nationalism, ideology and political institutions, and examines Christian-Muslim dialogue with particular relationship to the rise of Arab, Indian and Turkish nationalism.

More information »

 

Not for Sale CoverNot for Sale

This is a must read for all those seeking to understand the issues surrounding sexual exploitation and abuse in our society today - the human cost of UK prostitution today and the scourge of trafficking for sexual exploitation exposed to our senses as never before.

More information and Sample Chapters »